Have Your Say

Discuss Marple

Talk about everything Marple related here!

Griselda's son's name

ampman 31 Jul 09 at 10:15 a.m. GMT

I have recently been re-reading 4.50 from Paddington and The Body in the Library. One thing that puzzles me is that in this the Vicar's son is called David and in the other he is called Leonard. Are there any more inconsistancies in any of the other books?

Login or register to add posts and reply

6 replies

Reverse order

TheButlerDidIT 17 Oct 09 at 2:32 p.m. GMT

I'm pretty sure Dennis was his nephew in Murder at the Vicarage which I recently finnished reading. Then again I could be wrong.

ampman 23 Aug 09 at 10:13 a.m. GMT

Having re-read Murder at the Vicarage I discovered that the Vicar's nephew is called Dennis so back to square one.

susandiane

leonard is the vicar's nephew (murder at the vicarage). david is the vicar's son (4:50 from paddington).  david also appears (as an infant) in "body in the library"

aznm 12 Aug 09 at 10:43 a.m. GMT

I haven't read these two books in ages, but I can say that Dame Agatha DID indeed change the names of a few characters from book to book.  Raymond's girlfriend/fiancee was originally "Joyce" in an early book but later his wife was referred to as "Joan".  Speculation is twofold.  Either Raymond was with two women, dating Joyce, then later marrying Joan, or an error was made by Agatha Christie and no one caught it.  Thus, Raymond's Mrs. became "Joan" permanently.  There are other examples but I chalk it up to not keeping a character index and/or poor editing.  "Let's get Marple to the presses ASAP.  We need them on the shelves before Christmas."  That sort of thing.

susandiane 08 Aug 09 at 9:50 p.m. GMT

leonard is the vicar's nephew (murder at the vicarage). david is the vicar's son (4:50 from paddington).  david also appears (as an infant) in "body in the library"

ampman 06 Aug 09 at 9:20 a.m. GMT

No, in Chapte 15 of The Body in the Library Miss Marple goes to the vicarage to ask if there is any fund raising going on so that she has an excuse to call at Basil Blake's house and talk to Dinah Lee. On entering the vicarage drawing room she finds Griselda  playing with baby David who is crawling on the hearth rug. By the  time we reach 4.50 from Paddington David has become Leonard and is home from boarding school for Christmas.

Tommy_A_Jones 03 Aug 09 at 1:14 p.m. GMT

I have heard people mention that sometimes Raymond's wife changes from Joyce to Joan or it might be the other way round. I thought Grizelda's son wasn't born until after Body In The Library.