Have Your Say

Discuss Tommy and Tuppence

Talk about everything Tommy and Tuppence related here!

not my favorite detectives

biscotte 11 Feb 09 at 6:26 p.m. GMT

I love all the books i read until now, except for the tommy and tuppence stories.

Login or register to add posts and reply

28 replies

Reverse order

ariadnepoirotmarple 11 Feb 09 at 8:26 p.m. GMT

Well, biscotte, I think all AC characters are intersting and I think Tommy and Tuppence are excellent detectives. Everyone has a different point of view. Why don't you like them?

Tommy_A_Jones 12 Feb 09 at 3:57 p.m. GMT

I think Tommy and Tuppence are Great real Caper stories, I only have Postern of Fate left and then one day will read them again in Chronological order this time, They are my Favourite Detectives.

biscotte 16 Feb 09 at 4:12 p.m. GMT

I think i didn"t like them as much because they are younger caracters.  Funny saying this, but i like Miss Marple the most because she is old. I find it so amusing the way she finds out things by playing the dithering old lady. I also like Poirot because of his age. The way he always takes care of dressing warmly enough to prevent chest colds.

There is nothing wrong with Tommy and Tupence, but I personnaly prefer the relaxing "atmosphere" i get from reading Poirot or Miss Marple.

When I read a Poirot mystery, i feel transported in a world of luxory and calm intellect.

With Miss Marple, it's a world of small victorian houses, fancy tea sets, fluffy whool and artrhitis which i find very entertaining and relaxing.

When i read a Tommy and tuppence mystery, i find they are a bit  more "jumpy" and more modern. Also once in a while they reffer to other detective stories which i am never familiar with...

All AC detectives are good, but my favorites are Poirot and Miss Marple because the personnal lives of those caracters have a slower pace.

ariadnepoirotmarple 17 Feb 09 at 1:47 p.m. GMT

That's very intersting, biscotte! I also like Miss Marple and Poirot better than Tommy Tuppence (although I do like them a lot!) but I think it's because they are both peculiar detectives, unique characters and they are so original and methodic. The atmosphere of Tommy and Tuppence is a bit different, yes. But that's great for me because I can "run away" from the typical Christie book and discover that Agatha Christie had so many different styles and she was so diverse.

Tommy_A_Jones 17 Feb 09 at 3:06 p.m. GMT

I like Tommy and Tuppence because there is something quest-like (If there is such a word) about the books, their Adventures come about through ways that are out of the ordinary, When Agatha Christie wrote Tommy and Tuppence Books to some extent she thought out of the box to use a modern expression When I read a Tommy and Tuppence story I am transported to a World Escapeism and dare I say Daring-do, With Poirot there is an element of of Traditional Murder Mystery about him which although I gatha Christie wrote too many books with him in. I like the way that except for A CARRIBEAN MYSTERY Agatha Christie confined her to England. I like the departure from the calm (that is got from Poirot and Miss Marple stories) that you are sure not to have with Tommy and Tuppence, I also get this feeling with Bundle Brent stories and WHY DIDN'T THEY ASK EVANS, I like all three sets of books but like T&T; a bit more.

ace_of_spades 03 Mar 09 at 11:35 p.m. GMT

I've only yet read The Secret Adversary with Tommy and Tuppence, but I really enjoyed the book. Although T&T may not have as distinct personalities as the tidy, methodical Poirot, and shrewd, observant Miss Marple, there's something very human and realistic about them... I also appreciate having two detectives (one of each gender) working together in a Christie novel.

Tommy_A_Jones 03 Apr 09 at 2:19 p.m. GMT

I think Tommy and Tuppence have very distinctive personalities, they both have common sense but Tommy is more sensible as he gets older whereas Tuppence lets her imagination run riot and is the instigator of the sleuthing.

aznm 12 Aug 09 at 1:59 p.m. GMT

Tuppence is definitely the more impulsive, the more enthusiatic of the two, but Tommy has his adventurous side, thankfully.  Someone does have to real Tuppence in once in a while, doesn't one?  Tommy is just the one to do it.

I enjoy their lighthearted banter, their affection for each other, their wit, and their adventurous spirits.  People say Agatha Christie's characters are undeveloped but I think her detectives, esp. Poirot, Marple, and T&T are quite developed.  We can read their stories and know what they'll be doing to catch the rat.  We know them well enough to appreciate their skills.

With T&T, I especially like how they work together, care about each other, and play along the way.  They have great analytical minds in most adventures, and they've dealt with international spies.  I also like their settings of after WWI, then the 1920s, the WWII years, and then into the 1960s+.  It's great watching them advance, grow more mature, and do it with the times.  We never see this with Poirot and Marple, as they were both senior citizens when we first met them.

Lone_Wolf 20 Aug 09 at 1:43 p.m. GMT

I like their personalities just fine. They are like a bunch of fresh air. However, I find that the plotting of stories with them isn't that good. I easily guessed the villains in "The Secret (not-so-secret, really) Adversary" and "N or M?", and "By The Pricking of my Thumbs" left me so confused, I can't even remember the plot.

Besides, I can't really take the threat from the one-dimensional eeevil commmiez which is a central theme in "The Secret Adversary" and "Partners in Crime" seriously.

Frndorfoe 21 Aug 09 at 1 p.m. GMT

biscotte

I think i didn"t like them as much because they are younger caracters.  Funny saying this, but i like Miss Marple the most because she is old. I find it so amusing the way she finds out things by playing the dithering old lady. I also like Poirot because of his age. The way he always takes care of dressing warmly enough to prevent chest colds.

There is nothing wrong with Tommy and Tupence, but I personnaly prefer the relaxing "atmosphere" i get from reading Poirot or Miss Marple.

When I read a Poirot mystery, i feel transported in a world of luxory and calm intellect.

With Miss Marple, it's a world of small victorian houses, fancy tea sets, fluffy whool and artrhitis which i find very entertaining and relaxing.

When i read a Tommy and tuppence mystery, i find they are a bit  more "jumpy" and more modern. Also once in a while they reffer to other detective stories which i am never familiar with...

All AC detectives are good, but my favorites are Poirot and Miss Marple because the personnal lives of those caracters have a slower pace.

I agree with every word of this post. it's like biscotte has said everything I ever wanted to say about Miss Marple, Poirot and T&T!

go_leafs_nation 21 Aug 09 at 3:16 p.m. GMT

The problem with T&T is that AC hardly feels "at home" writing about them. Her best books are country house murders, I'd say. Thrillers aren't really in her line, but I did love By The Pricking of My Thumbs.

Bundle_ 21 Aug 09 at 5:27 p.m. GMT

I like the Tommy and Tuppence characters, a lot. However, like many of you pointed out, the stories are just not that interesting. I think that Partners in Crime was my seventh or eighth book that I read of AC's (which is about 2 years ago now) and I haven't picked up another T&T book since :0(.

Dianala 21 Aug 09 at 9:46 p.m. GMT

I love Tommy and Tupence I believe they are fantastic characters, what i like most are their personalities I only had the possibility to read two stories about them and I have recently watched a film called By the Pricking of My Thumbs which was adapted in 2005 by the French director Pascal Thomas with the title Mon petit doigt m'a dit.... The movie casts André Dussolier and Catherine Frot as Bélisaire and Prudence Beresford. The action is transposed to Savoy. A second movie Le crime est notre affaire based on "Partners in Crime" came out in 2008

go_leafs_nation 23 Aug 09 at 3:47 p.m. GMT

Mon petit doigt m'a dit was a rather strange film. I prefered the McEwan version, to be honest. The update didn't work too well in the French version, although I must admit "Mrs. Lancaster's" (now renamed "Rose Evangelista") voice was amazing.

Tommy_A_Jones 05 Sep 09 at 2:14 p.m. GMT

I thought it was Hillarious that Characters clothes colour coordinated the Rooms they were in and I thought Patrick Barlow was funny but it is a pity the only way we could see the Book being Dramatized is by it being part of the Marple Series.

Lil_Bit 17 Jun 10 at 5:43 a.m. GMT

It's hard to compare T&T to the other detectives. They're really not the same sort of stories. Marple and Poirot are generally used in standard detective stories, whereas T&T stories tend to be more thrillers than mysteries.

I will say, though, that I found Partners in Crime a bit disappointing. The stories were too short; there was really no time to develop the plots, and the solutions came across as amazing coincidences more than anything else.

Tommy_A_Jones 17 Jun 10 at 4:24 p.m. GMT

The Stories in Partner's in Crime were short because they were short stories, I liked them, I also like the way Agatha Christie managed to make sure Tommy and Tuppence could brush up their skills with the help of other Litrerary Detectives and Managed to get their Prey in the end with the Help of Hercule.

belgian_in_ireland 28 Jun 10 at 7:17 p.m. GMT

I must admit that I always have had a soft spot for T&T.  Partners in crime was the first AC I ever read at age 14, followed by The Secret Adversary.  I also love the television series with Francesca Annis & James Warwick.  They were just perfect for the roles.

As to the length of the stories, I agree that some of them now seem a bit on the short side.  But then of course on the other hand, some of the detective that she uses for the short stories are fairly unknown now, apart I would say Father Brown.

Tommy_A_Jones 25 Jun 11 at 4:05 p.m. GMT

belgian_inireland Father Brown is one of tghe More wellknown ones (Or is it me) I had never heard of the Oakewood Brothers or Inspector French or that lone man (Can't remember his name, ( iam re-reading The Secret Adversary and can't wait to read Partners in Crime 

ananya2410 25 Oct 11 at 3:22 a.m. GMT

i have read only one tommy and tuppence book-by the pricking of my thumbs and i like it. i like tuppence's curiosity to know about the house which led to the mystery though i feel the start is a little boring and at some places it is also spooky. i feel tuppence faints too many times.i too feel it is the or one of the best christie series. poirot also is good.