Have Your Say

Non-series Books and Characters

Other Christie books discussions

Superintendent Battle

pegahorse 02 Jan 09 at 5:20 a.m. GMT

I really enjoy the "Battle" books....Why doesn't Superintendent Battle appear in Fav Detectives?....Personally The Secret of Chimneys is the best retreat on a rainy day

Login or register to add posts and reply

22 replies

Reverse order

Tommy_A_Jones 10 Mar 11 at 4:57 p.m. GMT

Supt Battle WAS in Cards On The Table along with Poirot, Race and Ariadne but Battle and Race were taken out of the Adaptation and replaced  but Battle and Ariadne were in the Play and Poirot and Race werent in the Play.

I know it was mentioned yonks ago but I don't think George Baker would be too old but he looked unwell last time I saw him on Television, I think Jim Broadbent or Duncan Preston would be good as Battle.

Mr_Graves 22 Feb 11 at 7:22 p.m. GMT

Poirot is bad luck when it comes to parties! Of course, it may turn out like he had feared it would at the end of "Three Act Tragedy", that it could have been him that was poisoned. That does give me an idea....

MissQuin 21 Feb 11 at 4:33 p.m. GMT

Mr Graves- that's a superb list. I would never invite Poirot because every dinner party he attends ends in murder! Mr Pye wolud be a great addidtion because he knows the best gossip. Plus he value any antiques you have knocking round the place. Mrs Oliver would of course be very entertaining. The rest I think be charming companions.

Mr_Graves 21 Feb 11 at 4:44 a.m. GMT

I would invite Doctor Bessner and his lovely wife Cornelia, Ariadne Oliver, Colonel Race, Mr Satterthwaite, Mr Pye, Bobby and Frankie Jones, Rhoda and John Despard, and, as my guest of honour, Superintendent Battle. It would be nice if his daughter could join us, too. She sounds a charming creature...   

MissQuin 12 Mar 10 at 5:37 p.m. GMT

The dinner party list, I'll add Japp and Miss lemon.

MissQuin 05 Feb 10 at 3:13 p.m. GMT

ampman, are these the charcaters you wanted bumped off?

ampman 05 Feb 10 at 8:01 a.m. GMT

Gwenda and Giles from Sleeping Murder, they really annoy me, but it would have made a mess of the plot I suppose.

Miss Knight (?) that annoying woman who came to look after Miss Marple and nearly drove her mad.

Everybody in They Do It With Mirrors. Irritating weirdos.

Raymond West.........I just don't take to him.

Tommy_A_Jones 02 Feb 10 at 4:07 p.m. GMT

And Giles and his sister might not get on with him as I think they were a little intolerent of Miss Marple and Jerry might still be a little peeved that Miss Marple stole the show, Father (At Bertrams Hotel) would be at Poirot and Miss Marple's too.

MissQuin 02 Feb 10 at 3:30 p.m. GMT

Ah, Tommy that would make a great evening.

As much as I like Poirot, I wouldn't invite him either. He might not find the dinner arrangements symetrical enough for his liking!

Tommy_A_Jones 02 Feb 10 at 1:26 p.m. GMT

I think that is an excellenty question Miss Quin, I will have to think about who I would like to invite, Apart from Miss Marple and Poirot I would probably invite Hastings, Dolly Bantry, Sir Henry Clthering, Dermot Craddock, Lucy Eyelesbarrow, Gyles and Gwends, Jerry (Is that his name?) and his sister from The Moving Finger, Colin from The Clocks, Supt Battle, Bundle and Bill, Hilary from Destination Unknown and ofcourse Tommy, Tuppence and Albert but that seems alot so I would probaly not include Poirot, Hastings, Miss Marple, Dolly Bantry, and Sir Henry and take them seperately out for a Meal.  

MissQuin 01 Feb 10 at 7:52 p.m. GMT

Battle looks wooden but is very interesting underneath..

Ah Tommy, youve given me an idea!

If you were having a dinner party, which AC charcaters would you invite? Miss Marple because she's so wonderful, Mr Satterwaite (who'd probably get along well with Miss M) Dolly Bantry, Captain Hastings, Mr Quin (add mystery), Lucy from the Hollow (to add some humour) and Charles from Dumb Witness, just because he's so good looking!

Tommy_A_Jones 28 Feb 09 at 3:17 p.m. GMT

There are some Agatha Christie Characters I would love to socialize with and Battle is one of them, as is Bundle, Bobby, Frankie and Tommy and Tuppence.

susandiane 14 Feb 09 at 9:14 p.m. GMT

I have a secret crush on Battle. The way he handles his daughter's problem in "Toward Zero"... Wouldn't all of us like to have a father like that?

Tommy_A_Jones 30 Jan 09 at 4:24 p.m. GMT

In the Joan Hickson version of 'At Bertrams Hotel George Baker played Chief Inspector Davy and the other Detective was played by Philip Bretherton who might be quite good as Battle if a little short.

squatty 29 Jan 09 at 6:26 p.m. GMT

Whenever I used to watch Inspector Wexford, I could always imagine George Baker playing Battle. Alas, now he would probably be too old and too linked with the character of Wexford to carry it off.

Tommy_A_Jones 28 Jan 09 at 3:58 p.m. GMT

Holly I think Battlem is far from wooden, he is one of my favourite Christie Characters, There used to be someone on this site called Mole and she thought perhaps Heoffre3y Palmer should play him, Good choice I think and so is Edward Woodward but after reading Towards Zero I think Clive Mantle would be better, or maybe even Hugh Laurie.

Holly 27 Jan 09 at 4:13 p.m. GMT

Battle was in the book version of "Cards On the Table", yes. But they replaced him with a different, made-up character for the film. Which, considering what they made of the policeman in the film version, was probably a good thing.

I can't really think of any actor who is "wooden" enough to play Battle at the moment. Hmmm... *runs off to fetch her thinking cap*

detectivepauljohn 27 Jan 09 at 10:45 a.m. GMT

I think he was in the book "Cards On the Table".

susandiane 26 Jan 09 at 10:32 p.m. GMT

I think Secret of Chimneys is hands down Christie's funniest book! Towards Zero is my all time favorite book period! The EVIL that that killer tries to perpetrate, SHEESH! To Winnebego1901, I think Edward Woodward might be good as Battle.

Tommy_A_Jones 16 Jan 09 at 4:41 p.m. GMT

I totally agree Holly, and that would mean the Bundle Books being done which would be great, Who could play Battle I wonder, Any Ideas?